Fructose: NOT The Enemy It’s Made Out To Be

Every day there seems to be another ‘expert’, journalist, book or website claiming fructose is dangerous, and the cause of a whole raft of health issues.

Fructose is in fact being used – unfairly, I believe – as a scapegoat, and being blamed for North America’s obesity problems.

In essence, fructose is a simple fruit sugar that occurs naturally in almost every single fruit and vegetable on the planet (except for Yams).

Quiz: Is Your Body TOXIC? Take the Test...
(get your free personalized report)

It is generally accepted that fruits and vegetables are an essential part of a healthy, balanced diet, and a diet without fruits and vegetables would be severely deficient in many essential nutrients.

Yet this relentless attack on fructose in the media has led to many people believing that fructose, in any form, is bad for them.

We have even had a number of people contact us asking us if they should reduce their intake of fruits and vegetables, or switch to lower-fructose fruits/vegetables in order to consume less of this so-called ‘deadly’ sugar.

The difference between Fructose and High-Fructose Corn Syrup

Fructose and high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS) are not the same.

Fructose:

As mentioned above, fructose is a simple sugar that naturally occurs in almost all fruits and vegetables.

Quiz: Is Your Body TOXIC? Take the Test...
(personalized report)

The specific amounts of fructose in a selection of fruits and vegetables can be seen in the table below.

Fruits and vegetables contain fiber and it is thought that this fiber helps the body to process fructose. The fiber also helps you to feel full, stopping you eating too much at once.  HFCS, on the other hand, contains hardly any fiber and so doesn’t have this effect.

One advantage of fructose is that it is metabolized differently than glucose, and because it doesn’t stimulate the body to produce insulin, it is low glycemic.

There is no question that fruits and vegetables are essential and SHOULD be eaten on a daily basis – otherwise you will not be healthy!

High-Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS):

can of spriteHigh-fructose corn syrup is not a completely natural product.

In 1957, an enzyme was discovered that can turn regular corn syrup (which has no naturally occurring fructose) into fructose. As this process has been improved on and modified, it has become much cheaper for companies to use the sweeter corn fructose syrup rather than standard white sugar to sweeten foods. (source: American Journal of Clinical Nutrition).

You will find high-fructose corn syrup (or HFCS) in almost all baked goods, sodas and fruit juices.

One misconception about HFCS is that it is completely different to processed white sugar – it isn’t. HFCS usually contains 55% fructose and 45% glucose, with regular sugar having a 50/50 split. (Source: Harvard Medical School)

HFCS: The Facts…

corn in a fieldThere are so many conflicting views out there, with some people blaming fructose for the entire obesity epidemic in North America.

Many of the initial studies which linked HFCS to weight gain have either been discredited, or attributed the extra weight gain to the number of calories consumed rather than the fructose itself.

Regardless of this, it is clear that consuming too much HFCS is unhealthy. An average can of soda contains up to 39 grams of HFCS, and research shows that the average American consumed on average 37.8lb of HFCS in 2008, along with 85.4lbs of sugar. That’s 1.6lbs of sugar per week! (Source: Wikipedia: US Government Data)

1.6lbs of extra sugar per week is way too much, and not healthy! And remember, this extra sugar is in addition to the natural fructose consumed through fruits and vegetables.

This places a heavy toxic load on your liver. Fructose, unlike Glucose, is converted by the liver into glycerol, which can raise levels of triglycerides. If this cannot be processed, it could increase the risk of heart disease.

Critics of HFCS point out that because the manufacturing process requires additional enzymes and changing the molecular structure of regular corn syrup, it is unnatural and difficult for the body to process.

Critics also argue that the cheap processing costs have allowed manufacturers to make their foods even sweeter, and offer upsizes (such as 64oz sodas).

Don’t Blame HFCS

overweight manAs you can see from the information above, there is no doubt that Americans are consuming way too much sugar, but to say the obesity epidemic has been caused by HFCS is not helpful, or true.

To me it seems like the ‘easy way out’ to blame the obesity epidemic on HFCS, or even fructose in general. It’s a way for ‘experts’ to generate publicity, people to sell books and journalists to sell newspapers.

The reasons behind the obesity epidemic are complex, and a whole range of factors are involved. To blame it on a single nutrient is short-sighted, masks the real problems and only serves to stop people taking responsibility for their diet and lifestyles.

The fact is that most Americans are not active, they overeat, are stressed and live in a toxic environment. Lifestyles have changed, which means that people consume more fast food and cook less freshly prepared meals than ever before.

The standard diet is nutritionally depleted: most people do not eat enough lean proteins, fruits and vegetables, and consume too many processed foods. Diets include too much sugar (including HFCS), flavourings, colourings and preservatives.

If we take a can of soda for example, it not only contains up to 39 grams of HFCS, but also an entire cocktail of toxic ingredients, which may do more damage to the body than HFCS (and diet sodas containing the artificial sweetener aspartame are much more deadly).

I would like to see the focus taken off HFCS, and put on people taking responsibility for making the right decisions when it comes to their diet and lifestyle.

I would also encourage people who talk or write about fructose to clearly distinguish between naturally occurring fructose and HFCS.

What You Can Do?

  • variety of fruits and vegetablesFirstly, don’t stop eating fruits and vegetables.  If you want to live a long and healthy life, you need to eat a varied diet which includes a range of fruits and vegetables, even those which naturally have higher levels of fructose.
  • Secondly, try to reduce your consumption of packaged or processed products in general. Not only will they have been sweetened with HFCS, but also probably contain a range of artificial nasties like colourings, flavourings, preservatives and other unpleasantness.
  • Demand healthy foods: Companies only produce foods that people want to buy; that is the law of economics and supply/demand.  If you demand natural, minimally refined, clean foods, companies will start producing these foods to meet the demands.
  • I would also suggest avoiding artificial sweeteners, which may be much worse for you than HFCS or regular sugar.  Also avoid Agave Sugar, which contains up to 97% fructose and is heavily processed. It may be promoted as a healthy alternative, but in my opinion (and some others’) it’s not!

I welcome your thoughts, below.

5 thoughts on “Fructose: NOT The Enemy It’s Made Out To Be”

  1. Yes I did see that study, it is clear that consuming high sugary drinks/foods is not healthy, but it is not the cause of an obesity epidemic or anywhere close to it – there are so many factors in play and it is just another reason for the media to jump onboard…

    (Remember sugary drinks don’t just contain HFCS they also contain a whole range of artificially and heavily processed chemicals).

    I wouldnt drink either, but if I had to choose I would take a regular can of soda over one sweetened with aspartame everytime.

    Why not spend time on a study to see whether educating people to see food as ‘fuel’ and encourage them to take ownership of their body and their diet and lifestyle has a long-term impact on weight – I am pretty sure it would!

  2. Agree with everything you say except the title. You seem to be saying only eat fructose in the form of fruit and vegetables, which is exactly what the experts like Lustig are saying.

    Personally I avoid all fructose except that found in veges and a couple of pieces of fruit/day. I lost at least 14 kg and no longer suffer from gout. No longer weigh myself, but my clothes are getting looser.
    I do not just see food as only fuel, it has important social implications as well. When I eat plenty of saturated fat, adequate protein and very little fructose I feel great, have lots of energy and feel amazingly cheerful.

  3. Thanks Julian, you are correct that is what I am saying, but I am also saying that I don’t think people (mostly the media) should imply that HFCS is ‘the thing’ that has caused obesity issues in developed nations – the problem is much bigger than that and the media has been fixated on HFCS.

    As mentioned above there are ingredients that are, in my view, worse than HFCS (like aspartame for example)

  4. I appreciate your reply. We agree on almost everything. Fructose is not the whole problem of course, there are also aspartame and other non food sweeteners. However, it is a huge part of the problem. Going back to your title, an enemy remains an enemy even after you realise it has allies.

Leave a Comment